Mexican-american war the physical beginning of the mexican-american war between the united states and mexico began with a mexican attack on american troops who were stationed on the southern border of texas on april 25, 1846. Students will analyze the causes of the mexican-american war and then argue whether or not it was justified objectives in this extended writing task, students will read, analyze, and gather relevant information from text(s) and write an argumentative essay. The united states was justified in going to war because mexico had shed american blood on american soil, texas (a land that many mexicans still considered theirs) was an independent republic and had the right to govern itself, and texas was trying to become part of the united states, which means that the united states had a right to be involved. The mexican-american war was a war between the united states and mexico which lasted from april 1846 to february 1848 it stemmed from the united states' annexation of texas in 1845 and from a dispute over whether texas ended at the nueces river (mexican claim) or the rio grande (us claim. Despite the mexican-american skirmish occurring in disputed territory, president polk won overwhelming support from both the senate (40-2) and the house (174-14) for going to war doc b: how does this document help answer the mini-q question: was the us justified in going to war with mexico.
The mexican-american war general winfield scott's entrance into mexico city, september 14, 1847, is depicted in this print by carl nebel when war broke out against mexico in may 1846, the united states army numbered a mere 8,000, but soon 60,000 volunteers joined their ranks. The mexican government had two choices: they could give in and reestablish friendly relations to the united states, proving to the world that mexico would always be a slave to the united states or the mexican government would not surrender to such degradation and resort to war. The idea of manifest destiny was foreshadowed by some of the writings during the revolutionary times, with the desire for canada in the period between the american war for independence and the war. In which john green teaches you about the mexican-american war in the late 1840s, and the expansion of the united states into the western end of north america in this episode of crash course, us.
Was the us justified or unjustified in going to war with mexico there were big wars in the past, but have you heard of the mexican-american war in 1821 was the mexican independence, in 1845 was the texas annexation by the us, 1846-1848 was the mexican war, and in 1848 was the mexican cessation. The mexican-american war lasted for two years, with the united states winning the war and gaining more than five-hundred thousand square miles of northern mexican territories american political views regarding the mexican-american war were divided. The united states in 1846 was not justified in going to war with mexico the united states did not have proper justification to respond with violence against the mexican government the war with mexico was also a product of the united states' belief of manifest destiny. A third reason the mexican war was not justified was because expansion of slavery there were 103,000 whites and 38,000 slaves in 8121 along with mexico receiving its independence they made slavery illegal.
Mexican-american war 1 last resort the united states-mexico war partially abides by this principle although the united states and mexico wished to resolve the territorial dispute peacefully, the two nations resorted to the use of force. The mexican-american war was waged between the united states and mexico from 1846 to 1848 learn more about the causes of the mexican-american war and its outcome. Mexican american war argument (america justified) essay sample in 1836, after a deadly war, the texans successfully gained independence from mexico and formed the lone star republic. Mexican-american war, also called mexican war, spanish guerra de 1847 or guerra de estados unidos a mexico (war of the united states against mexico), war between the united states and mexico (april 1846-february 1848) stemming from the united states' annexation of texas in 1845 and from a dispute over whether texas ended at the nueces river (mexican claim) or the rio grande (us claim. The mexican american war was unjustified due to americas over bearing power and want for land.
The mexican-american war was one of the most controversial events that occurred in the 19th century both nations claimed that the other was at fault for causing the war the mexicans may have had their reasons for thinking so however, the americans were equally justified, if not more, in going to war with mexico. A second reason the mexican war was justified was an invasion that mexico has passed the boundary of the us (doc b) james polk, an american political wrote to the senate and house of representatives that was a war message from the president. Background essay mexican-american war mini-q was the united states justified in going to war with mexico america's wars have often been controver. Almost certainly it was not what is unusual about the mexican-american war is the sheer amount of contemporary, forget historical, debate about the rightness of the war more so than any other foreign war in american history, including vietnam and iraq, the mexican-american war was controversial and divisive from the very start.
Of course it was unjustified, a justified war is almost non-existent this was 1847 though land-grabs and land disputes were common place, and the relative enlightenment shared by many today only existed in too few. Transcript of was the united states justified to going to war with mexico so in conclusion, the mexican-american war was started by three reasons the americans wanted to expand their land, polk used propaganda to bring the war, and there was an aurgument over slavery. Was the mexican-american war justified i do not believe that the mexican-american war was justified the americans only aligned with texas because they eventually wanted control of the republic, and other areas that belonged to mexico.